Short answer: to choose a digital marketing agency, ask how it measures sales, who owns the accounts and the data, who will run your project day to day and what happens if results do not come. A good agency answers with process and numbers. A weak one answers with promises, likes and pretty reports.
In this article
- Before you search: what you need to be clear on
- The ten questions that separate good agencies from weak ones
- Red flags in the conversation and in the proposal
- How to compare proposals with different prices
- What to expect in the first 90 days
- Frequently asked questions
Before you search: what you need to be clear on
The best way not to get it wrong is to know what you are buying. Before the first meeting, write down three things:
- The goal as a number. Not "grow on social media", but "go from 20 to 35 sales a month" or "fill the clinic's calendar with consultations".
- How much you can invest in total. Separate the ad budget (which goes to Meta and Google) from the agency fee (the service). A lot of confusion comes from mixing the two.
- How sales happen today. On the website, on WhatsApp, by phone, in store? Who answers? Is there a CRM? This defines how much of the work is ads and how much is infrastructure.
With that in hand, you can judge whether the agency is proposing something that solves your problem or just selling the package it already has.
The ten questions that matter
1. How do you measure sales, not just leads?
This is the most revealing question. A good answer talks about lead source, CRM, sales stage and sending conversions back to the platforms. A weak answer talks about reach, clicks and cost per lead. Understand the difference in the article on cost per lead vs cost per sale.
2. Will the ad accounts, the pixel and the domain be in my name?
Ad accounts, business manager, Google Analytics, Tag Manager and the website domain should be yours, with the agency added as a partner with access. If you ever part ways, the history and the data stay with you. An agency that creates everything in its own name keeps clients for the wrong reason.
3. Who will run my project?
Ask for the name and role of the person who will manage the campaigns, how many clients that person handles and who your point of contact is. The partner shows up in the sales meeting. Day to day, the work may be done by someone else, and you need to know who.
4. What do you do in the first weeks?
A good start includes an audit, a tracking review, account cleanup and a testing plan. If the answer is "we launch campaigns tomorrow", be careful: launching campaigns without proper measurement is spending money to learn very little.
5. What does the report look like and how often?
Ask for a real example, with the client's data hidden. A good report shows spend, leads, sales, cost per sale and return by channel, plus what will be done next. We explain what a dashboard should include in the article on marketing dashboards.
6. Do you handle what happens after the click?
An ad that leads to a slow page, or to a WhatsApp that nobody answers, burns budget. Ask whether the agency looks at the landing page, the customer service and the CRM, or whether its responsibility ends at the click.
7. Do you have cases similar to mine?
Ask for examples from the same industry or with the same sales model: local service, online store, consultative sale. Ask what went wrong in those cases and how it was fixed. Someone who only tells success stories is probably hiding the process.
8. What is the contract?
Check the minimum term, exit penalty, notice period and what happens to the assets created (creatives, pages, automations). Long contracts without justification and high penalties are a sign the agency depends on locking clients in.
9. How much do you recommend investing in ads, and why?
The answer should start from your goal and your margin, not from a standard number. See how to do this math in the article on how much to spend on paid ads.
10. What happens if results do not come?
No serious agency guarantees sales numbers, because results also depend on your product, price and customer service. But the agency needs a plan: which signals it tracks, how soon it reviews the strategy and how it decides to change course.
Red flags
- Guaranteed results in sales or revenue, without knowing your operation.
- Focus on followers and likes when your goal is sales.
- Reports that only show platform numbers, never numbers from your cash register.
- Pressure to close with a discount that expires today.
- No access: you cannot log into your own accounts.
- A generic answer to everything: the same plan for a clinic, a store and a factory.
- Nobody asks about your margin or how your team handles leads.
How to compare proposals with different prices
Proposals often come with very different prices because they include different things. Build a simple table to put them side by side:
| Item | Agency 1 | Agency 2 | Agency 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ad platforms included | |||
| Creative production (how many per month) | |||
| Tracking and Conversions API | |||
| Landing page or website | |||
| CRM and automations | |||
| Reports and meetings (frequency) | |||
| Contract and penalty | |||
| Monthly service fee |
Once the table is filled in, the comparison stops being "which one is cheaper" and becomes "which one solves my whole problem". Sometimes the most expensive proposal ends up cheaper, because it saves you from hiring three other companies for the website, the CRM and the tracking.
What to expect in the first 90 days
| Period | What should happen |
|---|---|
| Weeks 1 and 2 | Audit, access, tracking review, campaign plan and tests |
| Weeks 3 to 6 | Campaigns live, first audience and creative tests, page and customer service adjustments |
| Weeks 7 to 12 | Cost per sale by channel, budget moving to what works, a stable reporting routine |
If by the end of that period you still do not know how much a sale from your ads costs, something important was left out.
How to run the first meeting
The first meeting with an agency says a lot about what the day-to-day will look like. A few habits help you get more out of it:
- Bring numbers. Approximate revenue, average ticket, how many leads arrive today and how many become sales. The more the agency knows, the more concrete the proposal.
- Show your accounts. If you already advertise, give read access to the ads manager and Analytics. A serious agency will point out problems during the conversation, such as duplicated conversions or campaigns without tracking.
- Watch the questions. A good agency asks more than it talks. It wants to know how your team handles leads, how long it takes to answer, what your margin is and what has already been tested.
- Ask for a 30-day plan. It does not need to be detailed, but it needs to exist. "We will see later" is not a plan.
- Ask who decides when something goes wrong. If a campaign starts spending without results on a Saturday, who sees it and who acts?
Specialist agency or full-service agency
Some agencies do one thing very well, such as Google Ads or social media, and others handle all of demand generation, from the ad to the CRM. Specialists work when the rest of your structure is already in place: a fast website, correct tracking, an organized sales team. When those parts are still loose, hiring only the ads usually leads to an endless argument about whose fault it is when sales do not show up. In that scenario, an integrated operation, where the same team is accountable for the whole path to the sale, tends to deliver results faster.
Whatever the model, the question stays the same: at the end of the month, can someone show you how much each new customer cost?
Frequently asked questions
Agency or freelance media buyer?
A good freelancer can work very well for smaller operations focused on one platform. An agency makes more sense when you need several fronts at once, such as ads, website, tracking and CRM, and continuity when someone goes on vacation.
Is it worth hiring an agency just to make posts?
If the goal is sales, organic posts alone rarely move the number in the short term. They help with reputation and social proof, but predictable lead generation usually comes from ads, search and well-run customer service.
How soon should I evaluate the agency?
Three months is a fair period to see the structure working and the first sales readings. Before that, evaluate the process: organization, transparency and speed of response.
Summary
- Define your goal as a number, your total budget and how sales happen before you search.
- Ask how the agency measures sales and require accounts and data in your name.
- Know who will run the project and see a real report.
- Compare proposals by what they deliver, not just by price.
- Within 90 days you should know how much a sale from your ads costs.